top of page

Heart Disease: Is it the sugar or the animal fat?

Recent research continues to provide evidence supporting the connection between diet and heart disease. Specifically, studies have found associations between the consumption of red meat, processed meat, and sugar, and an increased risk of cardiovascular disease.

Burlap bag showing sugars and animal products: Image Source: Bing Image Creator
Burlap bag showing sugars and animal products: Image Source: Bing Image Creator

The link between diet and heart disease has been a topic of debate for decades, with various dietary components falling in and out of favor as scientific understanding evolves. In the early 20th century, the role of dietary fats in heart disease became a major focus. The "diet-heart hypothesis" proposed that saturated fat and cholesterol in the diet led to increased blood cholesterol levels and subsequent heart disease.

However, in recent years, the focus has shifted from fats to other dietary components. One reason for the focus on single nutrients or food groups is that they are easier to study. Nutritional epidemiology often relies on observational studies where people's diets are assessed, and their health outcomes are tracked over time. It's easier to ask people about their intake of specific foods or nutrients rather than their whole dietary pattern.

Still, diet is complex, and focusing on single nutrients often oversimplifies this complexity. It's important to consider the whole dietary pattern, the food matrix, and how different nutrients interact. For example, while red meat is high in saturated fat, it also contains many other nutrients, including protein, iron, and B-vitamins. Similarly, sugar-sweetened beverages are high in sugar but also often contain other additives.

Moreover, people's dietary habits are intertwined with other lifestyle factors. For instance, someone who consumes a lot of red meat might also be more likely to smoke, exercise less, and have a higher overall calorie intake. These factors could confound the relationship between diet and heart disease.

As we move forward, the field of nutritional science is likely to increasingly recognize this complexity. More nuanced methodologies, such as machine learning and metabolomics, are being used to study dietary patterns and their impact on health. Personalized nutrition, which takes into account individual genetic variation, is also a growing field.

With this in mind, let's delve into some recent studies examining the relationship between the consumption of red meat, processed meat, and sugar, and the risk of heart disease.

A study conducted by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) involved close to 30,000 participants. It found that individuals who consumed two servings per week of red or processed meat had a 3% to 7% higher risk of cardiovascular disease, including heart attack and stroke. Additionally, they had a 3% higher risk of death from all causes. The study did not find an association between eating fish and cardiovascular disease or mortality (NHLBI, 2020).

Furthermore, a study published in BMC Medicine investigated the dietary habits of over 110,000 individuals in the United Kingdom across approximately nine years. The researchers differentiated between free sugars and those found in whole foods. Free sugars are sugars that are added to foods or drinks, or found in honey, syrups, and fruit juices, while whole foods like fruits and vegetables contain sugars naturally along with beneficial fibers.

The study found that each 5% increase in the proportion of a person's total energy intake that comes from free sugars was linked with a 6% higher risk of heart disease and a 10% higher risk of stroke. Conversely, sugars present in whole foods, which are typically consumed along with fiber, were not associated with an increased risk of heart disease or stroke.

Interestingly, the study also noted that higher fiber intake was associated with a lower incidence of cardiovascular disease. This further underscores the protective effect of consuming sugars from whole foods, which are often high in fiber, as opposed to consuming free sugars (BMC Medicine, 2023).

These studies provide significant insights into dietary impacts on heart disease, highlighting the importance of moderating the intake of red and processed meats and sugars. It's crucial to understand that these are correlations and may not necessarily indicate causation. Factors such as lifestyle, genetics, and other health conditions also play a key role in heart disease development.

Moreover, when discussing the health implications of red and processed meats, the method of preparation is a crucial factor. Cooking techniques can influence the nutritional profile and potential health risks of these foods. For instance, certain methods of cooking, such as high-temperature frying or grilling, have been shown to produce carcinogens like acrylamides and heterocyclic amines. Therefore, while meat in moderation (and I am using this term loosely) might not significantly impact heart health, the broader context, including cooking methods and frequency of consumption, should be considered.

In the upcoming article, we will delve deeper into these factors, expanding on the potential risks associated with the preparation and consumption of red and processed meats. This will provide a more comprehensive understanding of dietary impacts on heart health.


BMC Medicine. (2023). Associations between types and sources of dietary carbohydrates and cardiovascular disease risk: a prospective cohort study of UK Biobank participants.

NHLBI. (2020). New study shows that eating red meat, processed meat increases heart disease risk. NHLBI, NIH.



bottom of page